- 1999-00
- French Connection
- Double Dutch
- Denis Bergkamp
- 2002-03 Robert Pires
- Edu
- Sylvain Wiltord
- 2006-07 Robin van Persie
- Robin van Persie
- Abou Diaby
- Kolo Touré
- Philippe Senderos
- Júlio Baptista
- William Gallas
- Eduardo da Silva
- Alexander Hleb
- Łukasz Fabiański
- Gaël Clichy
- Manuel Almunia
- Nicklas Bendtner
- Emmanuel Eboué
- Håvard Nordtveit
- Armand Traoré
- Vito Mannone
- Kieran Gibbs
- 2008-09 Eduardo da Silva
- Andrey Arshavin
- Robin van Persie
- 2011-12
- 2012-13 Arsène Wenger
- Robin van Persie
- Thierry Henry
- 2013-14 Robin van Persie
- Li Ke
- 2014-15 Mathieu Flamini
- 2015-16
- Arsène Wenger
- Mathieu Flamini
- Mesut Özil
- Nacho Monreal
- 2016-17 Arsène Wenger
- Mesut Özil
- 2021-22 Takehiro Tomiyasu
- Gabriel Martinelli
- 2022-23 Aaron Ramsdale
- Ben White
- Bukayo Saka
- Martin Ødegaard
- Gabriel Jesus
- William Saliba
- Gabriel Martinelli
- 1997-98 Ugo Ehiogu
- 2001-02 Peter Schmeichel
- Boško Balaban
- 2008-09 Martin O'Neill
- Brad Friedel
- Luke Young
- Steve Sidwell
- Martin Laursen
- Gareth Barry
- Ashley Young
- James Milner
- Marlon Harewood
- John Carew
- Gabriel Agbonlahor
- Stuart Taylor
- Curtis Davies
- Nathan Delfouneso
- Zat Knight
- Moustapha Salifou
- Stiliyan Petrov
- Nigel Reo-Coker
- Nicky Shorey
- Isaiah Osbourne
- Brad Guzan
- Carlos Cuéllar
- Craig Gardner
- Erland Johnsen
- 1998-99 Marcel Desailly
- Roberto Di Matteo
- Gianluca Viali
- Tore André Flo
- Roberto Di Matteo
- 2000-01 Jesper Grønkjær
- Gianfranco Zola
- 2007-08 Petr Čech
- Claude Makélélé
- Ricardo Carvalho
- Frank Lampard
- Joe Cole
- Didier Drogba
- John Obi Mikel
- 2007-08 Michael Ballack
- Claudio Pizarro
- Wayne Bridge
- Carlo Cudicini
- Shaun Wright-Phillips
- John Terry
- Alex
- Juliano Belletti
- Henrique Hilário
- 2008-09 Petr Čech
- Branislav Ivanović
- Ashley Cole
- Michael Essien
- Ricardo Carvalho
- Frank Lampard
- Joe Cole
- Didier Drogba
- Michael Ballack
- Florent Malouda
- Scott Sinclair
- José Bosingwa
- Wayne Bridge
- Paulo Ferreira
- Deco
- Carlo Cudicini
- Nicolas Anelka
- Franco Di Santo
- Didier Drogba
- 2009-10 Carlo Ancelotti
- Petr Čech
- Branislav Ivanović
- Michael Essien
- Frank Lampard
- Joe Cole
- Didier Drogba
- Michael Ballack
- Florent Malouda
- Yuri Zhirkov
- Salomon Kalou
- Daniel Sturridge
- Nemanja Matić
- John Terry
- Alex
- Sam Hutchinson
- 2010-11 Petr Čech
- David Luiz
- Paulo Ferreira
- Frank Lampard
- Didier Drogba
- John Obi Mikel
- Salomon Kalou
- John Terry
- Nicolas Anelka
- Jeffrey Bruma
- 2011-12 Petr Čech
- Ramires
- Ashley Cole
- Ramires
- Frank Lampard
- Fernando Torres
- Juan Mata
- Didier Drogba
- Florent Malouda
- Raul Meireles
- Romelu Lukaku
- Josh McEachran
- Daniel Sturridge
- John Terry
- Didier Drogba
- Boudewijn Zenden
- 2012-13 Petr Čech
- Gary Cahill
- Frank Lampard
- Fernandeo Torres
- Juan Mata
- Oscar Emboaba
- Eden Hazard
- Paulo Ferreira
- John Terry
- César Azpilicueta
- Ramires
- 2013-14 Petr Čech
- David Luiz
- Frank Lampard
- Juan Mata
- Oscar Emboaba
- André Schürrle
- Kevin de Bruyne
- Marco van Ginkel
- Demba Ba
- Willian
- Gary Cahill
- John Terry
- John Obi Mikel
- César Azpilicueta
- 2014-15 Nemanja Matić
- Filipe Luís
- Robert Kenedy
- 2015-16 Asmir Begović
- Cesc Fàbregas
- Kurt Zouma
- Oscar Emboaba
- Radamel Falcao
- Eden Hazard
- Alexander Pato
- Bertrand Traoré
- Robert Kenedy
- Pedro Rodrigues
- Loic Remy
- Willian
- Gary Cahill
- John Terry
- César Azpilicueta
- Ola Aina
- Ruben Loftus-Cheek
- Tore André Flo
- 2000-01 Niclas Alexandersson
- Stephen Hughes
- Steve Simonsen
- Francis Jeffers
- Thomas Gravesen
- Paul Gascoigne
- Abel Xavier
- 2002-03 Richard Wright
- Li Tie
- Li Weifeng
- Thomas Gravesen
- Joseph Yobo
- Tobias Linderoth
- David Weir
- Lee Carsley
- 2003-04 Niclas Alexandersson
- Joseph Yobo
- Nigel Martyn
- 2004-05 Joseph Yobo
- Tony Hibbert
- Alessandro Pistone
- Mikel Arteta
- Gary Naysmith
- Kevin Campbell
- Leon Osman
- 2022-23 Jordan Pickford
- Amadou Onana
- Ben Godfrey
- Conor Coady
- 1997-98 Colin Calderwood
- 1999-00
- David Ginola
- David Ginola
- 2007-08 Paul Robinson
- Pascal Chimbonda
- Lee Young-Pyo
- Didier Zokora
- Teemu Tainio
- Jermaine Jenas
- Dimitar Berbatov
- Robbie Keane
- Steed Malbranque
- Gareth Bale
- Kevin Prince Boateng
- Jermain Defoe
- Adel Taarabt
- Michael Dawson
- Wayne Routledge
- Aaron Lennon
- Ledly King
- Ben Alnwick
- Ricardo Rocha
- 2009-10 Luka Modrić
- 2010-11 Younes Kaboul
- Tom Huddlestone
- Aaron Lennon
- Robbie Keane
- Luka Modrić
- Peter Crouch
- Jermain Defoe
- Michael Dawson
- Carlo Cudicini
- Ledley King
- Heurelho Gomes
- Benoît Assou-Ekotto
- 2011-12 Aaron Lennon
- Harry Kane
- Eric Dier
- 2018-19 Kieran Trippier
- Son Heung-Min
- Dele Alli
- Fernando Llorente
- Lucas Moura
- Kyle Walker-Peters
- 2020-21 Son Heung-Min
- Jose Mourinho
- 2021-22 Tang Jiali
- 2022-23 Hugo Lloris
- Ben Davies
- Son Heung-min
- Richarlison
- Harry Kane
- Ivan Perišić
- Jan Mølby
- 1994-95 Steve McManamann
- 1999-00
- Robbie Fowler
- Michael Owen
- Rigobert Song
- Sami Hyypiä
- Robbie Fowler
- Michael Owen
- 2001-02 Michael Owen
- 2002-03 Michael Owen
- Harry Kewell
- El Hadji Diouf
- 2004-05 Boudewijn Zenden
- 2006-07 Steven Gerrard
- 2012-13 Pepe Reina
- Raheem Sterling
- 2017-18
- 2018-19 Jürgen Klopp
- Fabinho
- Virgil van Dijk
- Naby Keita
- Roberto Firmino
- Sadio Mané
- Mohamed Salah
- Alisson Becker
- Jordan Henderson
- Xherdan Shaqiri
- Andrew Robertson
- Trent Alexander-Arnold
- 2019-20 Virgil van Dijk
- Robert Firmino
- Sadio Mané
- Mohamed Salah
- 1973-74 Denis Law
- 2002-03 Kevin Keegan
- 2002-03 David James
- David Tarnat
- 2003-04 Kevin Keegan
- 2008-09 Mark Hughes
- Joe Hart
- Micah Richards
- Michael Ball
- Nedum Onuoha
- Michael Johnson
- Stephen Ireland
- Shaun Wright-Phillips
- Robinho
- Elano
- Darius Vassell
- Jô
- Javier Garrido
- Kasper Schmeichel
- Martin Petrov
- Dietmar Hamann
- Richard Dunne
- Ched Evans
- Tak Ben-Haim
- Benjani Mwanruwari
- Daniel Sturridge
- Kelvin Etuhu
- Shaleum Logan
- Nery Castillo
- Shaun Wright-Phillips
- Vincent Kompany
- Richard Dunne
- Jô
- Robinho
- Benjani Mwanruwari
- Kelvin Etuhu
- 2009-10 Emmanuel Adebayor
- 2010-11 Joe Hart
- James Milner
- Edin Džeko
- Jérôme Boateng
- Garetn Barry
- Yaya Touré
- 2011-12 Roberto Mancini
- Joe Hart
- Sergio Agüero
- Adam Johnson
- Mario Baloteli
- 2012-13 David Silva
- 2015-16 Joe Hart
- Bacary Sagna
- Vicent Kompany
- Pablo Zabaleta
- Fernando Reges
- Raheem Sterling
- Sergio Agüero
- Aleksandar Kolarov
- Willy Caballero
- Wilfried Bony
- Jesús Navas
- Kevin De Bruyne
- Fabian Delph
- Eliaquim Mangala
- David Silva
- Gael Clichy
- Nicolas Otamendi
- Bruno Zuculini
- Yaya Touré
- 2016-17 Bacary Sagna
- Pablo Zabaleta
- Fernando
- Raheem Sterling
- Willy Caballero
- Wilfried Bony
- Jesús Navas
- Kevin De Bruyne
- Fabian Delph
- David Silva
- Gaël Clichy
- John Stones
- Fernandinho
- Nicolás Otamendi
- Yaya Touré
- Kelechi Iheanacho
- 2018-19
- Claudio Bravo
- Kyle Walker
- Danilo
- Vincent Kompany
- John Stones
- Raheem Sterling
- İlkay Gündoğan
- Sergio Agüero
- Aymeric Laporte
- Eliaquim Mangala
- Fabian Delph
- Leroy Sané
- Bernardo Silva
- David Silva
- Benjamin Mendy
- Fernandinho
- Riyad Mahrez
- Nicolás Otamendi
- Ederson
- Daniel Grimshaw
- Gabriel Jesus
- Oleksandr Zinchenko
- Phil Foden
- Arijanet Muric
- 2019-20 Claudio Bravo
- Kyle Walker
- John Stones
- Raheem Sterling
- İlkay Gündoğan
- Gabriel Jesus
- Sergio Agüero
- Oleksandr Zinchenko
- Angeliño
- Aymeric Laporte
- Kevin De Bruyne
- Leroy Sané
- Bernardo Silva
- David Silva
- Benjamin Mendy
- Fernandinho
- Riyad Mahrez
- João Cancelo
- Nicolás Otamendi
- Brazil Ederson
- Phil Foden
- Eric Garcia
- 2020-21 Pep Guadiola
- Kyle Walker
- Rúben Dias
- John Stones
- Nathan Aké
- Raheem Sterling
- İlkay Gündoğan
- Gabriel Jesus
- Sergio Agüero
- Oleksandr Zinchenko
- Zack Steffen
- Aymeric Laporte
- Rodri Hernández
- Kevin De Bruyne
- Bernardo Silva
- Ferran Torres
- Benjamin Mendy
- Fernandinho
- Riyad Mahrez
- João Cancelo
- Ederson Santana
- Scott Carson
- Eric Garcia
- Phil Foden
- 1966 Bobby Charlton
- Bobby Charlton
- Denis Law
- Denis Law
- George Best
- George Best
- Willie Morgen
- Alex Ferguson
- Peter Schmeichel
- 1992-93 Eric Cantona
- 1994-95 Paul Ince
- 1996-97 Roy Keane
- Phil Neville
- David Beckham
- 1999-00 Andy Cole
- Ryan Giggs
- Dwight Yorke
- Dwight Yorke
- 2002-03 Fabien Barthez
- 2004-05 Gary Neville
- Phil Neville
- Wes Brown
- John O'Shea
- Mikael Silvestre
- 1998-99 Kenny Dalglish
- Philippe Albert
- Shay Given
- 2002-03 Shay Given
- Nikos Dabizas
- Jamie McClen
- Marcelino Elena
- Noiberto Solano
- Jonathan Woodgate
- Andrew O'Brien
- 2003-04 Jermaine Jenas
- Tony Caig
- Kieron Dyer
- Alan Shearer
- Gary Speed
- Amdy Faye
- Lee Bowyer
- Andy O'brien
- Darren Ambrose
- Celestine Babayaro
- Hugo Viana
- Olivier Bernard
- Aaron Hughes
- Laurent Robert
- 2004-05 Nicky Butt
- Steven Taylor
- Laurent Robert
- Patrick Kluivert
- Alan Shearer
- Charles N'Zogbia
- Laurent Robert
- James Milner
- 2005-06 Tony Caig
- Steven Caldwell
- Lee Clark
- Steve Harper
- Belözoglu Emre
- Scott Parker
- Stephen Carr
- Jean-Alain Boumsong
- Michael Owen
- Albert Luque
- Shola Ameobi
- 2007-08 Damian Duff
- Paul Huntington
- 2018-19
- Kenwyne Jones
- Lee Tadanari
- Maya Yoshida
- 2014-15 Ronald Koeman
- Maarten Stekelenburg
- Sadio Mane
- Victor Wanyama
- James Ward-Prowse
- Graziano Pellè
- Filip Đuričić
- 2015-16 Jordy Clasie
- James Ward-Prowse
- Matt Targett
- 2016-17 Stuart Taylor
- Harrison Reed
- Jordy Clasie
- Sofiane Boufal
- Dušan Tadić
- Steven Davis
- 2021-22 Theo Walcott
- 2022-23 James Ward-Prowse
- Adam Armstrong
- Willy Caballero
